In the agency procurement industry, you may frequently handle two types of invoices: Proforma Invoice (PI) and Commercial Invoice (CI). These two types of invoices play different roles in international trade, with different application scenarios and legal effects. Understanding the differences between them is crucial for ensuring the smooth progress of your transactions.
Formal invoice is an informal commercial document typically used before the formal contract is signed. It includes information such as product description, unit price, quantity, total amount, payment method, packaging, delivery time, etc.
I have compiled some main functions of formal invoices for you, including the following:
- Quantitative quotation: You can provide specific price information to the buyer, which facilitates decision-making.
- Sales confirmation: Prior to the formal contract signing, this can serve as proof of both parties’ intention to transact.
- Application for License and Approval: In some countries, formal invoices can be used by buyers as documents for applying for import licenses or foreign exchange quotas, providing convenience for buyers.
- Opening a letter of credit: Banks may require a formal invoice to understand transaction details in order to open a letter of credit.
Commercial invoice is one of the most important documents in export trade settlement, and all other documents should be prepared around it. The main functions of commercial invoices include the following:
- Customs clearance and settlement: Commercial invoices are key documents in international trade, used for customs clearance, settlement, auditing, tax declaration, and as legal records and proof of transactions. It ensures the legality and transparency of transactions, while simplifying the customs clearance process and reducing transaction risks.
- Recording transactions: Commercial invoices serve as formal transaction records for both buyers and sellers, with legal effect and providing legal protection for both parties.
- Audit and Taxation: Commercial invoices are important basis for enterprises to conduct financial audits and tax declarations.
The main difference between a Proforma Invoice (PI) and a Commercial Invoice (CI) lies in their purpose, legal binding force, and level of detail in their content：
1.Purpose and Timing:
The Proforma Invoice (PI) is used before the transaction is finalized, primarily to provide customers with a preliminary quote and terms of trade to facilitate negotiations and discussions.
It is an informal document, usually provided to customers before the contract is signed, allowing them to assess costs and prepare for subsequent trade processes. In contrast, the Commercial Invoice (CI) is used after the delivery of goods, serving as a formal sales document that records the specific details of the transaction and is a key document for customers to make payments and clear customs.
2.Legal Binding Force:
The Proforma Invoice (PI) does not have legal enforceability; it is more like a pre-transaction letter of intent used for communication and negotiation between parties.
On the other hand, the Commercial Invoice (CI) has legal force. Once confirmed by both parties, it becomes an official document that both sides must adhere to and is the formal record after the transaction is completed.
3.Level of Detail in Content:
The content of the Proforma Invoice (PI) is relatively simple, usually including only the basic description of the goods, quantity, unit price, and other core information to quickly inform the customer about the basic situation of the transaction.
The Commercial Invoice (CI), however, is more detailed; it not only includes detailed information about the goods but also covers price terms, payment conditions, delivery details, etc., providing specific guidance and proof for every step of the transaction. In short, the PI is a communication tool before the transaction, while the CI is the formal record and legal document after the transaction is completed.
In summary, the Proforma Invoice is a preparatory step before the transaction, used to determine order details; the Commercial Invoice is the formal record after the transaction, ensuring the protection of both parties’ rights and interests, and is used to complete the payment and customs clearance process.
In practical business, the process of operating these two types of invoices is also different. In order to help you better understand, let me introduce the following two processes for you:
- The operation process of PI: After preliminary negotiations, you need to prepare a formal invoice based on the customer’s needs, detailing the product information and transaction conditions for the customer to confirm.
- The operation process of CI: After the goods are shipped, you need to issue a commercial invoice based on the actual shipping details for customer payment and customs clearance.
In short, PI helps determine the order, while CI ensures that you receive payment and complete the customs clearance of the goods.
When using these two types of invoices, you need to pay attention to managing related risks:
1. Invoice Loss or Damage:
To prevent the risks associated with invoice loss or damage, it is recommended that you use an electronic document management system for electronic backup to ensure the security and reliability of your data. This way, even if a paper invoice is lost or damaged, you can quickly recover the data through electronic backups, ensuring business continuity.
2.Incorrect or Inconsistent Invoice Information:
To avoid tax issues caused by incorrect or inconsistent invoice information, you need to strictly verify all the information on the invoice to ensure its accuracy. This includes key details such as product names, quantities, prices, and making sure that the invoice content matches the actual transaction. By establishing a strict review process and internal control mechanisms, you can effectively reduce the likelihood of errors.
Different countries and regions have different regulatory requirements and standards for these two types of invoices, and you need to understand and comply with these regulations:
1. Regulatory Standards for Proforma Invoices:
In some countries, proforma invoices can be used as a basis for applying for import licenses, so they need to comply with local laws and regulations. This means that you must ensure that the proforma invoice contains all the necessary information to pass the review process smoothly.
2.Regulatory Standards for Commercial Invoices:
Commercial invoices typically need to include specific information such as HS codes, taxes, shipping fees, insurance premiums, etc., to comply with international customs clearance standards. This information is crucial for customs to determine duties and other taxes, so you must ensure the accuracy and completeness of the commercial invoice to avoid delays or additional costs in customs clearance.
Modern technologies, such as invoice recognition technology, can improve the efficiency and accuracy of invoice processing:
1.Reducing Labor Costs:
Invoice recognition technology can replace a large amount of manual data entry work, reducing labor requirements. By automating invoice data processing, you can save time and resources while reducing errors caused by manual operations.
2.Reducing Human Errors:
Through machine learning and artificial intelligence technologies, invoice recognition systems can accurately extract invoice information and reduce errors. These technologies can automatically compare invoice information with related documents such as purchase orders and receiving reports, identifying anomalies and thus reducing the risk of financial fraud for businesses.
Let’s illustrate the application of these two types of invoices through a real-life example. Suppose you are a Chinese electronic component manufacturer, and your American client, ABC Company, plans to import a batch of electronic components from you.
1.Initial Negotiations and Use of PI:
Based on the needs of ABC Company, you prepared a proforma invoice (PI) that detailed the types, quantities, unit prices, total prices, payment terms, delivery dates, and shipping methods of the electronic components.
This PI helped ABC Company to evaluate and negotiate, and it was also used to apply for import licenses and foreign exchange quotas from relevant U.S. departments.
2.Shipping and Use of CI:
After the completion of the goods shipment, you issued a commercial invoice (CI) that included all the details of the transaction. ABC Company used the commercial invoice for customs clearance and settlement upon receipt.
Understanding the differences and applications of PI and CI is crucial for your business in international trade. They not only help you clarify the terms of the transaction but also ensure the legality and transparency of the deal. As a procurement agent, we advise you to deeply understand the importance of these documents and use them correctly in practical business to improve efficiency and reduce risks.
We look forward to working with you to explore the infinite possibilities of the global market. Contact Us – Let’s work together to create success.